3 Best Peanut Butters [Creamy, Crunchy, Vegan, Organic]

Good peanut butter can be hard to find, but it doesn’t have to be. Whether you want crunchy, creamy, organic, or vegan, find your new favorite store-bought peanut butter here.

best store bought peanut butter

If you are looking for organic and vegan options, we’ve got you covered! No matter what kind of crunchy or smooth texture you prefer, this article has the best choices for all tastes and dietary restrictions.

SKIPPY Creamy Peanut Butter

Skippy Creamy Peanut Butter is best for fans of the classic or traditional peanut butter taste. This jar comes with organic peanuts and just enough sugar to create that perfect flavor balance. Skippy’s creamy peanut butter has an easy-to-spread consistency that won’t leave you feeling like your fingers need a good scrubbing.

Our favorite store-bought peanut butter is sweet, salty, creamy, and fluffy. In addition to having a well-balanced seasoning, our taste testing team also noted Skippy Creamy’s roasted flavor and strong peanut flavor.

Our taste testers felt that this spread had a “faint aftertaste” that would bother people who prefer all-natural products.

This pick didn’t rank well in the health category, with a single two-tablespoon serving has 16 grams of fat and 3 grams of sugar.

When you need a peanut butter fix, there’s no better option than Skippy. You can’t go wrong with any of the different flavor varieties and textures that they offer – each is notably fresh-tasting and smooth. If you’re looking for classic, smooth peanut butter, this is the brand for you.

If you enjoy a deep nutty flavor, the Skippy brand might not be for you. You’ll still want to eat it all, though, because their peanut butter is delicious.

Jif Creamy Peanut Butter

The classics never go out of style. If you’re looking to revisit your childhood memories, this is a great way to do so.

If you want something reliable at the store or are making sandwiches for kids who aren’t all that picky about what they put on them, then go ahead and get some Jiffy Peanut Butter! It’ll never let you down!

The only one in my taste test that I wanted to eat by itself, and it just so happened it was the best tasting too. Thick with a nice crunch without being overpowering and a fantastic light flavor as well.

This peanut butter lives up to its name by offering creamy goodness without tasting too salty or bitter yet still packing that crunch.

Skippy may be creamier, but Jif is by far the tastiest. The crunchy peanut butter also has more flavor varieties. You don’t buy peanut butter for its consistency or texture-you buy it because of how good it tastes.

Jif’s peanut butter has a sweet taste from the molasses that doesn’t overwhelm the peanuts. The result is an overall sweeter flavor than other products but with enough balance to make it functional as a product for your morning toast.

Maranatha Organic Creamy Peanut Butter

Maranatha Organic Creamy Peanut Butter is best for those who want a healthy peanut butter option. The company uses organic ingredients and sweeteners, making this one of the best options if you care about what goes into your food. It’s also 100% vegan-friendly, with no added sugar or hydrogenated oils to worry about.

It can be challenging to find organic peanut butter that is also vegan-friendly and doesn’t separate. MaraNatha manages to tick every box. It contains only peanuts and palm oil to create a healthier, flavorful version of peanut butter.

This creamy version has more texture than other brands but isn’t as crunchy as many would like. That being said, it tastes delicious and will be perfect on toast in the mornings.

This peanut butter tends to divide people. Some people love its deep and natural flavor profile, while others might find it bland.

This non-salted peanut butter has a hint of sweetness but is not overly sweet or salty. An excellent down-the-middle choice.

Ordinarily, most people prefer sweeter or processed peanut butter. However, this option tasted saltier than sweet and felt the soft, smooth texture would work well on their sandwich or piece of toast.